Skip to main content

Vital Accountax Limited

The best way to choose an accountant is to ask the same set of questions to two or three firms and compare the answers. Focus on four things: whether they are qualified and supervised, whether they understand businesses like yours, exactly what their fee includes, and how they will work with you day to day.

Below are the questions worth asking, grouped by topic, with what a good answer looks like.

Before you start: know what you need

First, write down what you actually need help with. For example:

  • year-end accounts and a Corporation Tax return
  • Self Assessment for you, or for each director
  • VAT returns, payroll or CIS
  • bookkeeping, or just a review of your own books
  • advice on tax, structure or cash flow

This list makes quotes comparable. It also stops you paying for services you do not need.

Questions about qualifications and regulation

1. Are you a member of a professional body?

In the UK, anyone can call themselves an accountant. The title itself is not protected. However, terms such as chartered accountant and chartered certified accountant can only be used by members of the relevant bodies, such as ICAEW, ICAS, ACCA or CIMA. AAT members are also qualified and regulated.

A good answer names the body and the person’s membership.

2. Who supervises you for anti-money laundering?

By law, accountancy firms must be supervised for anti-money laundering (AML). This is usually by their professional body or by HMRC. If a firm cannot tell you who supervises it, walk away.

3. Do you have professional indemnity insurance?

Professional indemnity insurance protects you if an error causes you a loss. Regulated firms normally hold it. It is a fair and simple question to ask.

Questions about experience

4. Do you work with businesses like mine?

An accountant who already works with sole traders, contractors or limited companies like yours will spot issues faster. Ask for the types of clients they usually support. You do not need names; a general answer is fine.

5. Which areas do you specialise in?

Some firms focus on property, construction or e-commerce. If your business has specialist rules, such as CIS or marketplace income, check that they deal with them regularly.

6. Who will actually do my work?

Ask whether you will have a named accountant or a shared team. Continuity matters. A person who knows your business will give better, quicker answers.

Questions about fees

7. Is your fee fixed, and what does it include?

A clear answer lists each filing and service. Ask for it in writing. Our guide on how much an accountant costs explains what usually drives the price.

8. What would cost extra?

Common extras include HMRC enquiries, late records, extra companies or one-off advice. Knowing these upfront avoids surprise bills.

9. How do you charge for questions?

Some packages include unlimited reasonable contact. Others bill for calls. Either is fine, as long as you know before you sign.

Questions about working together

10. Which accounting software do you use?

Most firms now work with cloud software such as Xero, QuickBooks, FreeAgent or Sage. Check they support the one you use, or ask which they recommend and why.

11. How do I send you my records?

A secure client portal is safer than email attachments. Ask how documents are shared and stored.

12. How quickly do you usually reply?

You do not need instant answers. Still, a typical response time tells you a lot about how a firm runs.

Questions about deadlines and tax

13. How will you keep me on track with deadlines?

A good accountant tracks your filing and payment dates for you and reminds you in advance. Ask how they do it.

14. Will you tell me what I owe before it is due?

Tax bills should never come as a surprise. The right accountant gives you an estimate early, so you can plan your cash flow.

Red flags to watch for

On the other hand, some answers should make you cautious:

  • no professional body and no clear AML supervisor
  • a very low price with a vague list of what is included
  • pressure to sign up immediately
  • no named contact or no way to reach a person
  • promises of tax savings before they have seen your figures

Should you choose a local accountant?

Not necessarily. Many businesses now work with an accountant entirely online. Others prefer someone nearby for occasional face-to-face meetings. Our comparison of online vs local accountants looks at the pros and cons of each.

Ready to compare?

If you are in Greater Manchester, you are welcome to put these questions to us. At Vital Accountax, you deal directly with our accounting team, receive a fixed quote before any work starts, and share documents through a secure client portal. Talk to a Manchester accountant or request a quote.

Frequently asked questions

What qualifications should an accountant have in the UK?

Look for membership of a recognised body such as ICAEW, ICAS, ACCA, CIMA or AAT. Membership means the accountant has passed exams, follows a code of ethics and must keep their knowledge up to date.

How many accountants should I speak to before choosing?

Two or three is usually enough. Ask each the same questions, so you can compare like for like.

Can I change my accountant if I am not happy?

Yes, at any time. The new accountant contacts your old one for professional clearance and handover. See our step-by-step guide on how to change your accountant.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *